Thursday, July 10, 2008

Risks And Follies of More Financial Regulations

It seems that our financial gurus in Washington, D.C. have finally put their brain on autopilot and left their mouths on auto “rant.” I know Hank Paulson has been doing this for a while, with his well-worn rant of "We want a strong dollar. A strong dollar is in our nation's interest.” (For those interested, there is a drinking game devised by Paul Kedrosky, based on Paulson’s strong dollar rant. Click here for the rules.)

And now, with Ben Bernanke, one of the few voices of reason in the government, calling for a consolidated oversight of investment banks, there doesn’t seem to be anyone in Washington, D.C. who is willing to face the facts that trying to heal a ailing economy with more regulatory duct tapes and rhetorical rants.

According to Bloomberg, Ben said: “Congress should give a single federal regulator enhanced power to set standards for the capital, liquidity and risk management of investment banks,” in his testimony to the House Financial Services Committee today. “He also asked for a procedure to liquidate failing investment banks and for Fed powers over payments systems.”

Mr. Bernanke, such a single federal regulatory body exists: The SEC. Perhaps, we should let the SEC do what it was founded to do: “The mission of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is to protect investors, maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets, and facilitate capital formation.”

A Quick Romp Through Recent History Of Knee-jerk Regulatory Actions

1 – The Great Depression
Congress created the SEC in response to the Great Depression. SEC, with the passage of the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, had the responsibility to restore investor confidence in the capital markets by providing more reliable market information and clear rules of honest dealing.

I doubt that SEC is fulfilling its mandated mission if financial crises continue to occur with such regularity.

2 – S&L Crisis of 1980’s
The Savings & Loans crisis in the 1980’s led to the government adding another layer of regulation through the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA). All this regulation did was to shutter existing agencies, create new ones, and shuffle existing government staffers from the old agencies to the new agencies. Change the nameplates, slap on a new cost of regulatory whitewash and everything is now supposed to be better and improved.

One of the interesting regulations that came out of this was the new capital reserve requirement that banks had to meet to ensure that they can weather the financial downturns. (FYI, this requirement was rescinded in 1990; so much for regulations.)

3 – Dot Com crash
With the blow up of Enron and other similar high-flying companies, the Congress rushed and passed the now infamous Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX). Infamous in that it added such a deep layer of needless complexity, large public companies are still, to this day, trying to comply with its requirements. In a nutshell, SOX made it a criminal offense to falsify or sign falsified financial reports and held the CEO accountable. Also, it created a quasi-governmental agency, Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), and charged it to define the audit process and procedures.

My question on this is what really is the difference between PACOB and Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB)? Private versus public?

What’s Changed?
Astute readers would note that another financial meltdown happened, even after all the regulatory laws and governing bodies that have been created to prevent such an event. So what has changed? Much like the rest of human development, when one side comes up with a rule, someone else will come up with a way to circumvent it. This escalation is almost instinctive. On the positive, it drives innovation, leads to new discoveries, and growth of human civilization. On the negative, it drives those bound by greed or other selfish desires to find ways to gain at the cost of others’ suffering; a zero sum game.

Ergo, the same is playing itself out in the financial market. A similar meltdown will happen. It won’t happen in the same way. However, when it does happen – a matter of when and not if – it will look similar to the past meltdowns.

Mathematics calls this The Chaos Theory. For those investors who seek to understand why and what a near catastrophic financial meltdown is happening, look at the work done in weather prediction. It is similar to that of the financial market.

Getting Back On Point And Conclusion
So what does all these historical and mathematical diversions have to do with the main point? Simple.

A direct message to Mr. Bernanke: We haven’t learned from our past mistakes and, judging from the messages being sent out from Washington, D.C., it appears that we will very likely see a similar situation in the near future, regardless of how many more additional regulations and oversights you propose to add to the already motley mix.

Regards,
Ed Kim
Practical Risk Manager

Sphere: Related Content

Wednesday, July 9, 2008

Downgrade U.S. Government’s Credit Rating To "A2"?

With the news out that derivatives traders are treating Fannie Mae (Fannie) and Freddie Mac (Freddie) as if they should be rated “A2”, five levels lower than the implied government backed rating of Aaa. According to Bloomberg, “Credit-default swaps tied to $1.45 trillion of debt sold by the two biggest U.S. mortgage-finance companies are trading at levels that imply the bonds should be rated A2 by Moody's Investors Service,”

What the derivative market is saying, in essence, is that the likelihood of Fannie and Freddie being able to repay their obligations in full is in doubt. Taking this logic couple of steps further, since Fannie and Freddie have implicit backing of the U.S. Government, this implies that either (1) the implicit guaranty means nothing to the derivative market, and therefore they do not expect the government to bail out Fannie and Freddie; or (2) even with the implicit guaranty of the U.S. Government, the likelihood of being made whole is in doubt since the Government is already operating in a deep deficit.

Both scenarios bode very badly for the U.S. economy. I have stated this sort of problem in my March 19th article:

“Should losses in the 4% to 5% range occur, Fannie and Freddie will require immediate capital injection. Moreover, this would cause substantial losses in the market. After all, if Fannie and Freddie, the two truly “can’t fail” companies begin teetering, then the entire market will begin free falling.

The probability of this risk event unfolding is high given the continuing deterioration in the real estate market and with nearly $700 billion in ARM mortgage interest rate resets to occur in 2008. If the projected defaults increase substantially over the historic average, then the Federal Government will be forced to step in with tens of billions dollars in capitalization. And guess where that money is coming from.”

Let’s take some hypothetical looks at how this scenario might play itself out:

(1) Fannie and Freddie obtain capital injections from SWFs or private funds. The market will see the capital raise, as a red flag and drive the credit default spread even higher, a scenario that I think will definitely happen.

Since the cost of capital has increased substantially, the cost of the capital raise, in the capital market, will negatively affect Fannie and Freddie’s net income for years to come, if they can even obtain the capital. This too will have a long-term negative affect as more income is diverted to servicing the cost of capital. Again, the credit default spread will go even higher. This is another likely scenario, in my view. The stock prices of these two may see a little bounce; dead cat version, in my view.

(2) Fannie and Freddie fail to obtain capital injection or the funds raised are deemed to be inadequate. The market will see this as a very bad sign – double red flags – and begin abandoning their positions in Freddie and Fannie, and causing a substantial dislocation in the global market; a scenario that I hope does not happen but has an outside chance of occurring.

(3) The Federal Reserve, at the urging of the U.S. Government, steps in and provides the same short-term liquidity injection that Wall Street received (Term Securities Lending Facility). The Fed will take Fannie and Freddie’s junky bonds in exchange for UST (U.S. Treasuries), at very favorable terms. This, too, is a likely scenario, in my view.

This will increase the risks I have outlined in my March 11th article: (a) increasing the credit malaise, (b) driving away foreign investors in UST and causing the rates to rise, (c) lowering the value of the U.S. dollar, (d) driving the U.S. economy further into hyperinflation. While this move will lower the credit default swap spread, it will cause more upheaval in the bond market and drive the stocks of these two down substantially.

None of the three above scenarios are pretty. It is basically choosing the lesser of the evils at this point. It is clear at this point that the market does not believe the U.S. government’s desire to step into save Freddie and Fannie and any move by them to raise capital will trigger further widening of the default swap rate.

With the potential for housing prices to decline 10% to 20% further, the mortgages on Fannie and Freddie’s books are looking very suspect. A typical loss (haircut) given on the balance of a mortgage is 10%. Based on the $1.4 trillion in debt outstanding, a haircut of 10% results in a potential loss of $112 billion.

$1.4 trillion x 10% mortgage write-off x 80 cent loss per $1 = $112 billion in potential losses, nearly 146% of the estimated 76.8 billion in reserve capital, estimated as of December 2007.

Fannie and Freddie may not survive in their current form, after all the losses have been tallied. Batten down the hatches because here comes the other side of the hurricane!

Regards,
Ed Kim
Practical Risk Manager

Sphere: Related Content

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

Is There A Bright Side To The Current Economic Doom And Gloom?

Surprisingly, yes. In fact, there are lots of upside to all this doom and gloom.

The major beneficiaries of the economic downturn will be the American consumers. They just don’t realize it yet. Like a person trying to recover from a hangover, consumers are slowly realizing the high cost of their excessive lifestyle of living in a McMansion set in a former crop field miles from a major urban center.

Large ostentatious homes will be a relict of past frenzy, much like the Pet Rock craze. Consumers are also realizing that living in such a remote location is not as glamorous as it seemed at first: the long commute to work, the need to drive everywhere, trying to deal with wild creatures grazing in their yard or garbage can, etc.

The ever-increasing gas price has consumers seeking ‘green’ alternatives (or lat least more economical alternatives) to driving SUVs. Sales of bicycles and scooters are up. Electric vehicles, once derided as transportation of the ‘tree-huggers’ are now mainstream. Public transportation and car-pooling are even making a come back. Frugal is now vogue. People are driving less, downsizing their vehicles, conserving more, and seeking ways to reduce their total consumption costs.

Industries that will benefit
With consumers strongly signaling desire to reduce costs, those manufacturers that can meet the new consumer demand will benefit. And those companies are:

  • Makers of the next generation of lithium-ion batteries
  • Makers of solar energy: Electric Panels, Water Heaters, and Heat Pumps
  • Makers of Genetically Modified crops and seeds
  • Makers of Vertical hydro-farming
  • Green gas capture and trading
  • Makers of Green Construction Materials
  • The car manufacturer that comes to the market first with the economically viable 100-mpg car
I am most excited about the innovations in automotive design that should be hitting the showrooms around 2010-2011. With the advances in the next generation lithium ion batteries – no more of Li-ion batteries spontaneously combusting – we should see exciting versions of the electric cars. I can hardly wait to buy an electric hybrid car for about $20,000 that comfortably seats four, gets at least 100 miles per gallon, and still go from 0 to 60 mph in less than 5 seconds

Regards,
Ed Kim
Practical Risk Manager

Sphere: Related Content